Should You Get a Second Opinion on a Dementia Diagnosis?
Quite possibly. If your gut says the diagnosis doesn't add up, or if you've been told there's nothing that can be done, get another set of eyes on it. Here's how a second diagnosis changed everything for my mom, and what I learned along the way.
DEMENTIA


My mom had been in and out of the hospital because of an unstable heart. She was clammy and weak, and her color was off. She was also recovering from a stroke. During one of those hospital stays in December, the medical team decided to check her brain.
The neurologist delivered the news: dementia. In their view, the reason her heart couldn't be stabilized was that the problems were coming from her brain. There was nothing to be done. No medications. It sounded like we were nearing the end of my mother's downward health spiral.
As the neurologist and his team walked out of the room, a nurse came in to prep my mom's meds and told me I needed to be strong for my mother. And I was. I did the strongest thing I could think of: I got a second opinion.
Math is not my strong suit, but being analytical is (a blessing and a curse). And the logic wasn't there:
Her heart still needed care. I knew my mom's heart had issues. If her brain had issues too, I accepted that. But her heart still needed its own care, and we needed to find it at a different hospital.
"Nothing can be done" deserved more than a pop-in. I have a friend whose mother was diagnosed with dementia years earlier and had been on medication ever since. "No medications" and "nothing can be done" aren't quick, pop-in conversations, and we got no details or context.
So I stepped out of the room and called another hospital system in Houston. (One upside of living here: we have a lot of options when it comes to medical care.) I made an appointment with their neurology department. The first opening was three months away. I took it.
Next task at hand: get her heart stabilized.
Three months that went sideways
After another hospital stay, new medications finally got my mom's heart under control. Less than two weeks after she was discharged, at the beginning of February, she fell and broke her hip. Surgery followed, and by March she was in a rehab facility that I can only describe as twenty levels deep into Hades.
I was sleeping there at night, running home in the mornings when a close family friend relieved me, then coming back to work from the facility. It was hands down one of the worst times of my life.
So I forgot all about the neurology appointment until one of those automated calls reminded me the night before.
I scrambled. I told the staff, they arranged transport, and off we went. I don't think she'd recovered from the anesthesia yet. My mom was in another world, and she barely spoke to the neurologist at Baylor, Dr. Chi-Ying (Roy) Lin. I was heartbroken.
The appointment that changed everything
This neurologist wanted the whole story, and he took as much time as we needed.
As he listened, he turned his computer monitor toward me and said that everything I described matched the story her brain was telling. He showed me the vascular dementia and the stroke. Then he showed me something new: Alzheimer's. He pulled up a healthy brain so I could see the difference.
There are no FDA-approved medications for vascular dementia, but there are for Alzheimer's. He prescribed two for her to try. Unfortunately, she was already in a later stage, so we'd missed medications that work only in the early stages and can help slow the disease. He also told me that after a stroke, the brain has about six months to either recover or not. We'd just have to wait and see.
Sure enough, six months later, my mom was much better. She's improved even more since then. We're now just shy of four years from that first diagnosis. Had I heeded the doctors' words and given up, she wouldn't be rolling her walker around town today, perusing handbags and asking me to take her somewhere she can find a new husband.


About Dr. Lin
If you're looking for an Alzheimer's doctor in Houston, we can't recommend Dr. Chi-Ying (Roy) Lin enough. He's at Baylor Medicine's Alzheimer's Disease and Memory Disorders Center. He's up on the latest research and the latest medications. He listens to everything. He's responsive. And whenever I ask a question (and I ask more than one), he says, "That's a really great question." I've noticed all of my mom's doctors at Baylor do that.
My running joke: if Dr. Lin weren't using his powers for good, he could surely be Dexter. He's that meticulous. That thorough.
He's one of our favorite doctors to see, and I'm so grateful for him.
About Dr. Azeem
Dr. Amir Azeem is the doctor who fixed my mom's heart when no one else could. He's a board-certified cardiologist and cardiac electrophysiologist, which means he specializes in heart rhythm problems. He practices with Cardiac Rhythm Specialists in Houston and is affiliated with Houston Methodist and Memorial Hermann.
He's another family favorite. We love him too!
Why does a second opinion matter for dementia?
Second opinions can give you new insights, and in some cases, life-changing ones. The key is weighing what doctors tell you against what you know: your loved one's baseline behavior.
Doctors have the experience, the textbook knowledge, the degrees. But I know my mother. If you know your loved one, same, y'all. Same. You're the project manager who keeps it all together.
Dementia isn't always one thing, either (as in my mom's case). Dementia includes Alzheimer's, vascular, Lewy body, and frontotemporal, and according to the Alzheimer's Association, more than one can be present at the same time. That's called mixed dementia, and the most common form combines Alzheimer's with the blood vessel problems linked to vascular dementia. In studies at Alzheimer's Disease Research Centers, more than half of people with dementia showed evidence of more than one cause.
The diagnosis shapes treatment, too. When a doctor believes Alzheimer's is one of the conditions involved, they may consider prescribing the drugs approved for Alzheimer's. For us, the second opinion is what opened the door to medication.
I'm not a doctor, and this isn't medical advice. It's what happened to us and what I wish I'd known sooner.
Four things to know about dementia and complicated health situations
I'll go deeper on each of these in upcoming posts.
Don't chalk it up to old age. Know your loved one's baseline behavior. If something makes you go "huh" or "hmmm," pay attention.
Look at cognitive function early. If your loved one has Medicare, the Annual Wellness Visit is required to include a check for cognitive impairment. Ask for formal testing by name. Some medications only work in the early stages, and by the time my mom was diagnosed, we'd missed them.
Switch up their routine. Routines and muscle memory can mask decline. Spend a few hours or a weekend together somewhere new and watch how they do.
Find a doctor who's comfortable with your loved one's care. Some doctors shy away from complicated patients. If yours seems uncomfortable, it's okay to find a new one. Every change we made was worth it for my mom's quality of life.
How do you get a second opinion on a dementia diagnosis?
Step 1: Check your coverage
Original Medicare. Part B covers medically necessary doctor visits, and a visit to a second neurologist is one of them. After the Part B deductible, you typically pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount. You don't need a referral, but make sure the doctor accepts Medicare.
Medicare Advantage. These plans must cover at least what Original Medicare does, but they set their own rules. HMO plans usually require a referral to see an in-network specialist; PPO plans usually don't. An out-of-network doctor may cost more or not be covered. Plans vary, but my mother has a PPO for situations just like these. I didn't need a referral to book the appointment for the second opinion.
Texas Medicaid (STAR+PLUS). Your health plan's member handbook explains how to ask for a second opinion. Call the member services number on the card.
Employer or private insurance. Check whether the new neurologist is in network and whether you need a referral or prior authorization.
Whatever the plan, call the number on the back of the card and ask:
Is this doctor in network?
Do I need a referral or prior authorization?
What will I pay for the visit?
Are tests and imaging covered if the new doctor orders them?
Step 2: Choose the right second opinion
Go to a different hospital system. Doctors in the same system often share records, training, and habits, so they may land on the same answer. Fresh eyes mean a different system.
Look for a memory specialist. A memory clinic, or a neurologist who focuses on Alzheimer's and other dementias, sees these cases every day.
Consider an academic medical center. Teaching hospitals like Baylor tend to be up on the newest treatments, and Baylor's own neurologists point to clinical trials as a reason to get assessed at an academic center.
Don't put other problems on hold. While you wait for the neurology appointment, keep treating everything else. For us, that meant getting my mom's heart to the right cardiologist.
Step 3: Make the appointment count
Book now, even if it's months out. Then ask to be put on the cancellation list.
Set reminders a week and a day before. I almost missed ours.
Write a one-page timeline. Hospital stays, falls, strokes, medication changes, and behavior changes, with dates. A good doctor will want the whole story.
Get records and imaging sent ahead. Ask the new office exactly what they need, including brain scans, and request them early.
Bring your questions. What type (or types) of dementia is this? What stage? Are there medications worth trying? What should we watch for over the next six months?
Bring a second set of ears. Take notes or bring someone with you. It's a lot to absorb.
Leave with a plan. Ask when to follow up, what tests come next, and who to call if things change.
The bottom line
A second opinion is another set of data. Weigh it against the first one, and against what you know about your loved one. If something doesn't add up, keep asking. I got more than two opinions for my mom's heart situation.
Being strong for my mother didn't mean accepting the first answer. It meant asking for a second one.
Sources
Northwestern Medicine, Vascular Dementia Treatments
Alzheimer's Association, Navigating Treatment Options
Alzheimer's Association, Mixed Dementia
Thunell et al., Medicare's Annual Wellness Visit and Diagnoses of Dementias and Cognitive Impairment, Alzheimer's & Dementia: Diagnosis, Assessment & Disease Monitoring (2022)
Medicare.gov, Second Surgical Opinions
Medicare Interactive, Medicare Advantage Plan Network Comparison Chart
Baylor College of Medicine, Alzheimer's Disease 101: Recognizing Warning Signs and Understanding Risks
El Roi Media ©2026
From one caregiver to another...
Let's connect.
Subscribe and never miss a post.
Read how we protect your data in our privacy policy.
